A Change of Guard

សូមស្តាប់វិទ្យុសង្គ្រោះជាតិ Please read more Khmer news and listen to CNRP Radio at National Rescue Party. សូមស្តាប់វីទ្យុខ្មែរប៉ុស្តិ៍/Khmer Post Radio.
Follow Khmerization on Facebook/តាមដានខ្មែរូបនីយកម្មតាម Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/khmerization.khmerican

Monday 14 May 2012

Chut Wutty's memory spurs anti-logging campaign


A memorial service was held on Friday for Chut Wutty

“People seem to be exercising self-censorship - they're afraid of being prosecuted for defamation and incitement,”
The death of an environmental activist, shot dead by police, has galvanised his campaign against deforestation and illegal logging in a scenic part of Cambodia.
Ratanakiri is a beautiful province in the north of this country - with volcanic lakes, waterfalls and huge areas of unspoiled forest.
Most of the people who live there belong to indigenous hill tribes who worship spirits in nature.
But peace has brought smooth-surfaced roads and outsiders to rural parts of the country that were once remote.
The hill tribes complain that the newcomers try to trick them out of their traditional lands - and hack down the trees which make up what they call the "spirit forests".
A young man from the Tampeun people told me he knew where loggers were at work - and volunteered to show me. So we jumped into a battered pickup - and slithered along a narrow trail through the forest.
Suddenly we burst out into a clearing. And immediately it seemed that we had made a horrible mistake.
Chut Wutty was one of Cambodia's most outspoken activists
Among piles of cut timber, there was a group of young men who did not look thrilled to see us. Several were dressed in military fatigues - and at least a couple were toting AK-47 rifles. The only way out was behind us.


I jumped out of the car, smiled and shouted hello.
A slightly older man turned and beamed broadly. It turned out that not only did he speak English, but he was an avid listener to the BBC. Instead of being held at gunpoint, we were invited to lunch.
I remembered this incident, a few years on, when I heard about the violent death of Chut Wutty.
I knew him a little - he used to be a soldier before getting a job with the British environment monitor Global Witness, which meant he saw at first-hand the devastation of Cambodia's forests.
When his employers were kicked out of Cambodia for alleging connections between the government and illegal loggers, Wutty set up his own organisation.

He helped indigenous people to form forestry patrols to seek out and chase away illegal loggers. If they found piles of cut timber, they would burn it - making sure those who destroyed the trees would not not profit.
Wutty was good at PR as well as direct action. He brought hundreds of tribe members to Phnom Penh, where they painted their faces blue and dressed up as characters from Avatar.
Just like the aliens in the film, their forest world was being destroyed by greedy outsiders.
All these antics meant that Wutty was not short of enemies.
Some of them were extremely well-connected - holders of land concessions that activists said were being used as cover for illegal logging. But he had powerful friends as well - thanks to his military connections.
So it is ironic that he died at the hands of a military police officer.
And from a personal point of view it is haunting - because he was doing much the same as my young Tampeun guide in Ratanakiri.
Wutty was showing two journalists around an area which he believed was being illegally logged.
They ran into military police who demanded their cameras.
A heated argument developed, then the journalists heard gunshots and fled into the forest. When they emerged, Wutty was dead in the driver's seat of his Landcruiser and a military police officer lay prone on the ground.
As the journalists were surrounded by other men in uniforms, they overheard one say "just kill them". Thankfully that did not happen - they are both safe, if traumatised.
Yeak Laom volcanic lake, RatanakiriRatanakiri draws tourists to its lakes and forests
I do not believe Wutty was deliberately targeted. But his death is the most chilling example of what seems to be an increasing willingness to use armed force against protesters.
Just in the past three months, guards at a rubber plantation shot and wounded land protesters. The governor of Bavet city is facing charges for shooting at demonstrating garment factory workers.

And, in a reversal of the archetype, police threw stones at residents during an eviction in Phnom Penh.
The UN's visiting special envoy for human rights in Cambodia told me these were worrying developments.
UN envoy Surya Subedi is worried about the treatment of human rights activists in Cambodia
Surya Subedi went to pay his respects to Chut Wutty's family and he said that bullets were just one part of the threat to protest and freedom of expression in Cambodia.
"People seem to be exercising self-censorship - they're afraid of being prosecuted for defamation and incitement," he told me.
"I've shared my recommendations with the government - but the implementation is frustratingly slow and I'm disappointed with the progress made."
The government may be aware this is a slippery slope. It has suspended all future land concessions, though not those already in place.
Chut Wutty would probably have taken that as progress, but not victory. The indigenous people he worked with have promised they will continue the movement he started.
And that perhaps is the most fitting tribute to that intense, unorthodox and courageous man, who knew the dangers of his job and was prepared to accept them.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Who is the journalist if this article? It seems this journalist is trying to make it that Chut Vuthy was a military officer and he deserved to be killed. We need to know who wrote this rubbish, there is little report of his death or the leading investigation. This journalist must be well paid by CPP for the cover up.

Anonymous said...

The journalist is Guy De Launey,a BBC correspondent in Phnom Penh. Most of what he said was very correct, except I disagreed with him when he said Wutty was not deliberately targeted.

If Guy read what happened to Wutty in the past in almost the same spot he would not have said that. I believe Wutty was targeted because he had been to the same place around last year and they (police and provincial officials)threatened that if he ever come back, they would kill him.

Just after Wutty was killed, Radio Free Asia interviewed one of Wutty's friends, I think it was Chhim Savuth, who said that last year, Wutty led a group of tribal people to protest against logging in almost the same spot where he was killed. The police tried to arrest him on the spot, but he escaped to Koh Kong town and they followed him, pointed the guns at him and arrested him there. He was only released after the tribal people fought back to rescue him. After he was arrested and released, he was sternly warned that if he ever come back to the site again, he would be killed.

If people read the chain of event that happened on that day, they would know that it is a planned assassination because, first the police, who came drunk and wearing masks, wanted him to go with them to see their boss in Koh Kong. This was a ploy to bring him with them and kill him on the way in the jungle somewhere. But lucky, Wutty did not agree to go with them. And the way he was stopped from leaving the area with threatening manner and the way someone ordered the 2 journalists to be killed as well suggested that it was a planned assassination.

So, I believe that Guy did not get all the facts before he made the assumption that Wutty was not deliberately targeted. I think they planned to kill him based on the threats they gave Wutty not to come back and based on the actual accounts of witnesses of what happened on that day, like someone ordered the 2 journalists to be killed as well.

Anonymous said...

Target assassination or elimination no doubt...!
Cpp's thugs,planning to kill anyone who is in their way,the case of Chut Wuty or Chea Vichea
all planned by Cpp to get rid of any khmer's hero
whom is against their corrupted way of doing
business behind close doors.

Chut Wuty and Chea Vichea,is the case of Assassination or elimination was planning for a
long time in the making...!
V.C+Cpp wanted to get rid of all khmers heroism,
All from Hanoi Yuons the kooks who is in the progress of annex khmer's land.

Hanoi,was planning for decades ago to take Cambodia like Champa or Kampuchea krom...lucky today world has UN to oversea the aggressors like Yuons+Siam...

Koun Khmer